Out-of-State Investing: How to Screen Zillow Listings Remotely

Out-of-state investing works when your screening is strict and your local team is real—not when you trust a pro forma from a turnkey seller. Zillow is your eyes on the market; Realy is your underwriting layer.

---

Why Out-of-State Investors Use Zillow

• National inventory visibility
• Rent Zestimate as starting comp (verify later)
• Price history, DOM, reductions
• Photos and satellite context

Zillow does not replace local boots—but it finds candidates worth paying a local PM or inspector to visit.

---

Remote Screening Workflow

Phase 1: Market selection (before Zillow)

Pick 1–2 metros max. Criteria:

• Landlord-friendly laws (research separately)
• Population/job growth trends
• Insurance availability (avoid uninsurable zones)
• PM density (can you hire quality management?)

Phase 2: Zillow + Realy bulk screen

1. Set Zillow filters (price, type, beds)
2. Open Realy Analyzer on search results
3. Set conservative assumptions upfront:

1. Sort by cash-on-cash—not cap rate alone
2. Shortlist 5–10 listings max

Phase 3: Remote deep dive

For each finalist:

• Rent comps (Zillow rentals + Rentometer + PM opinion)
• Crime / flood maps
• Google Street View (block condition)
• Tax assessor record (TX guide)
• Red flags checklist
• Realy Detailed analysis → share with local PM for feedback

Phase 4: Local validation

Before offer:

• PM walkthrough video or drive-by
• Third-party inspection
• Lease verification if tenant-occupied (turnkey checklist)

---

Assumption Discipline (Critical Remotely)

Out-of-state investors fail by modeling self-manage assumptions from 1,000 miles away.

In Realy, always set:

Management Fee = 8–10% of gross rent
Vacancy = 1+ months
Maintenance = non-zero

Realy converts management % of gross rent in the calculation engine:

managementFeesAnnual = annualRents × managementFeePercent

Compare CoC before and after adding management—you'll eliminate half your "great deals."

---

Example: Dallas Remote Screen

From Top 10 Dallas rankings:

A listing showing 106% CoC with zero expenses collapses to 15–25% CoC after insurance, vacancy, and 8% management—still potentially good, but a different decision.

Always re-run numbers with remote-realistic assumptions before wiring earnest money.

---

Build a Local Team Before You Buy

---

Tools Stack for Remote Investors

→ Realy vs spreadsheet for why remote investors can't paste into Excel at scale.

---

Start Remote Screening

1. Pick your target market on Zillow
2. Install Realy
3. Set 8% management + 1 mo vacancy
4. Sort search by CoC; send top 3 to a local PM

Related: Turnkey analysis · Find cash-flowing rentals